Colony Credit Disappointed the Skeptics For a Change

Key points from 1Q19 results (Press Release, Financial Supplement, and Conference Call):

  • Undepreciated Book Value was $21.68 at 3/31/19.  BVPS fell by $0.13 from 12/31, but  the company generated a positive shareholder return with $0.425 of dividend payments.
  • “Core Earnings” of $0.38/share included some small non-recurring benefits.  Management suggested the quarter-end earnings run rate was $0.36, but reaffirmed expectations of covering the quarterly dividend by the end of 2019.
  • Private equity interests were sold in line with year-end carrying value, except for a small remaining balance held through partnerships.
  • New investments were largely offset by repayments and asset sales.  The company still needs to increase its assets by about $1Bn to reach its targeted leverage.
  • The typical blather from CEO Kevin Traenkle about not repurchasing shares.

Colony Credit is trading at a 28% discount to book value while large cap peers trade at an average 22% premium.

CLNC Comps 050819


Bloomberg reported that Colony Capital was in negotiation with Oaktree at the end of last year regarding a potential sale of its interest in Colony Credit (presumably the shares + management contract).  Those talks did not result in a transaction and Oaktree sold itself instead, however the talks illustrate that CLNC could be involved in a strategic transaction that would deliver value to CLNY and an improved outlook for CLNC’s public shareholders.

CLNC did not report any significant impairments in 1Q19.  During the conference call CEO Kevin Traenkle provided a vague response when asked about credit quality.  The 10-Q may have helpful details about the restructuring of the Row Hotel loan in New York City and other assets previously disclosed as troubled.


The author is a shareholder of CLNC.  The author does not make any recommendation regarding any investment in any company mentioned in this article.  Investors are encouraged to check all of the key facts cited here from SEC filings and other sources prior to making their own investment decisions.

2 thoughts on “Colony Credit Disappointed the Skeptics For a Change

  1. Hi- I’m curious if you have thoughts on CLNC post last week. The main thing I struggle with is getting confidence that the marks are correct (i.e. book is really worth over $17). They have clearly taken some massive writedowns and you would think they have been conservative enough since they are embarking on a disposition strategy for the non core assets. Also, its encouraging to see so much insider buying. But as your writeup revealed, sometimes these guys just don’t write down their assets quickly enough. Thanks.


    1. I posted a newer commentary here:

      How many times are these clowns going to hit the Reset button? The latest results were almost comically bad. The key points from that article remain valid.

      1) Management failed so the company should be sold.
      2) Value of assets has been overstated in the financial statements since the company came public.
      3) Management commentary has been consistently overoptimistic.

      I’ll probably publish some new comments within the next week. A few points:

      1) The Death Row Hotel was written down by another $50mm
      2) The internalization proposal is unwelcome. It would help CLNY divest its non-digital assets, but it would make CLNC more complex and less attractive to investors. Traenkle has been a disaster – he should be dumped rather than internalized.
      3) Bifurcation of the portfolio might facilitate sale of the “good” assets to a third party while placing the “bad” assets in a liquidating trust.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s